Why Most eBook Readers Are Rated “Good” or Better: Understanding the Grading System
The eBook reader market has grown significantly in recent years, and as a result, we’ve consistently tested new devices on ALLESebook.de. When discussions about the seemingly inexplicable grading system became quite heated in the comments and forum, we introduced a transparent grading system after careful consideration. The disputes over the ratings of eBook readers subsided, and initially, it seemed like everyone was content.
Recently, however, more voices have emerged criticizing the current grading scheme. For instance, an email from a visitor stated, “Why do you even bother testing eReaders anymore if they all end up being rated ‘very good’ or ‘good’?”
No Grade Without a Review
At first glance, the situation may seem striking when you look at our ratings list. However, there are two things to keep in mind:
1. Dedicated reading devices are primarily for reading eBooks. Our grading system consciously places the most importance on screen readability (37 percent) and reading comfort (13 percent). If both of these aspects are at a high level, you’re halfway there since such a device is well-suited for reading digital books. No matter how many functions an eReader might have, most of your time will likely be spent reading the actual book content, not in the main menu, not in the virtual library, not taking notes, and not purchasing eBooks.
2. The test grade primarily serves to compare all the devices we’ve tested. However, this doesn’t mean a lower-rated eBook reader is automatically a worse choice for varying needs. For instance, if you want to remain as independent as possible with an eBook reader, the high rating of the Kindle Paperwhite (Grade: 1.2) might be irrelevant. The grade should always be viewed in relation to the accompanying review. It describes all the advantages and disadvantages of each device, and only with this information can a reasonable purchase decision be made.
I find it less meaningful to change the weighting of the individual ratings just to achieve a broader range in the final grade.
Common Rating System
By the way, ALLESebook.de is not alone in this approach. Stiftung Warentest has also recently rated most of the eBook readers they tested with at least a good grade, considering screen quality as the most important quality feature at 40 percent, followed by usability at 20 percent.
The final grades of individual devices do differ due to various weightings, but the trend is the same: Almost all eBook readers are “good,” as the majority performs excellently at its core competency, reading. Particularly, the current generation of devices often offers proven display technology and great craftsmanship at affordable prices. If you just want to read, it’s hard to go wrong when purchasing a modern eBook reader. Of course, the comfort in handling and buying books will vary (sometimes significantly), but as mentioned, extensive reviews address any remaining questions about these differences.
In conclusion, it’s worth noting that not every individual rating should be criticized because ultimately, choosing the right device depends on personal preferences and requirements. The test grade we provide is intended primarily as an aid for decision-making, not a substitute for thorough research.
